| Date | Champion | Won From |
| 6/26/2007 | Harry Smith | Won 21 man battle royal, first ever champion |
| 10/17/2006 | Afa Jr. (Manu) | Harry Smith doesn't show to compete, belt awarded to Afa Jr. |
| 2/1/2007 | T.J. Wilson (Tyson Kidd) | Afa Jr. (ladder match) |
| 12/18/2007 | Ted Dibiase Jr. | T.J. Wilson (Tyson Kidd) |
| 1/19/2008 | Heath Miller (Heath Slater) | Ted Dibiase Jr. vacated title due to injury, title given to Heath Miller (Heath Slater) |
| 3/22/2008 | Jack Hager (Jack Swagger) | Last ever champion, Jack Hager (Jack Swagger) wins match and unified FCW Southern Heavyweight Championship and FCW Heavyweight Championship, FCW Southern Heavyweight Championship is then retired |