Order of Elimination
|WWE NXT Rookie||Final WWE Pro||Win-Loss Record||Eliminated|
|#5||Brodus Clay||Alberto Del Rio / Ricardo Rodriguez||7-3||March 1, 2011|
|#3||Byron Saxton||Dolph Ziggler
|3-6||February 8, 2011|
|#2||Conor O'Brian||Alberto Del Rio||3-1||
January 18, 2011
|#4||Derrick Bateman||Daniel Bryan||3-6||February 22, 2011|
|#1||Jacob Novak||Chris Masters||1-2||
January 6, 2011
X= Won NXT
Dolph Ziggler won a Pros' Challenge battle royal, and earned the right to trade his rookie for another rookie. Ziggler traded Jacob Novak for Byron Saxton, who was mentored by Chris Masters.
Brodus Clay won a Rookie Challenge Fatal 4-Way which allowed him to change Pros. He selected Alberto Del Rio as his WWE Pro.